United American vs Mutual of Omaha: Medicare Supplement Compared

united american vs mutual of omaha medigap is one of the most common comparisons Medicare beneficiaries make when shopping for supplemental coverage. Both carriers hold A+ ratings from AM Best. Both specialize in Medicare Supplement plans rather than Medicare Advantage. However, they differ in pricing methods, enrollment options, and extra benefits. United American is a subsidiary of Globe Life Inc. and uses issue-age pricing. Mutual of Omaha is a policyholder-owned mutual company with attained-age pricing. Understanding these differences helps you pick the plan that fits your budget and health needs for years to come.

United American Vs Mutual Of Omaha Medigap: Quick Comparison

The table above captures the core united american vs mutual of omaha medigap differences at a glance. Both carriers earn top-tier financial strength ratings. However, their pricing structures and extra benefits diverge significantly. United American keeps things simple with issue-age rates and agent-based enrollment. Mutual of Omaha bundles vision, hearing, and fitness discount programs with every policy.

In most cases, your choice will come down to two factors. First, do you want issue-age or attained-age pricing? Second, do you value bundled discount programs? These differences matter more over a 10- or 20-year policy than the initial monthly premium.

Medicare Plan Options: United American vs Mutual Of Omaha

Both carriers focus exclusively on Medigap supplement plans. Neither company sells Medicare Advantage HMO or PPO plans. This means you keep Original Medicare and add their supplement on top. According to medicare.gov, all Medigap plans with the same letter must cover the same benefits regardless of carrier. The difference comes down to price, service, and extras.

United American offers Plans A, F, High-Deductible F, G, and N. Plan G is their flagship product for anyone who became Medicare-eligible after January 1, 2020. Plan F remains available to those eligible before that date. On the other hand, Mutual of Omaha offers the same lineup plus High-Deductible Plan G. That extra option gives budget-conscious enrollees a way to lower their monthly premium in exchange for a $2,950 annual deductible in 2026.

Neither carrier offers standalone Part D prescription drug plans. Mutual of Omaha previously sold Part D plans but exited that market after 2024. For example, if you choose either company for Medigap, you will need to enroll in a separate Part D plan through another carrier. You can compare Part D options on the Medicare Plan Finder at medicare.gov.

Rates and Enrollment: United American vs Mutual Of Omaha

Pricing approach is the biggest practical difference in the united american vs mutual of omaha medigap comparison. United American uses issue-age rating. Your premium is based on how old you are when you buy the policy. Rates can still rise due to inflation and medical costs. However, you do not face automatic age-based increases each birthday. This approach typically costs more upfront but saves money over the long term.

Mutual of Omaha uses attained-age rating. Premiums start lower at age 65 but increase as you age. Historical rate increases for Mutual of Omaha tend to fall between 3% and 10% annually. Over 15 or 20 years, attained-age policies can become significantly more expensive than issue-age policies. For example, a 65-year-old might pay less initially with Mutual of Omaha but more by age 75.

Enrollment methods also differ. United American relies on licensed independent agents. You cannot buy directly online or over the phone without an agent. Mutual of Omaha offers three options: online quotes and applications, phone enrollment, and local agents. If you prefer handling everything digitally, Mutual of Omaha provides a smoother path. Many Medicare beneficiaries also carry a life insurance policy to protect their family, so you may want to compare life insurance rates at Life Insure Guide while reviewing your coverage.

Additional Benefits Compared

The united american vs mutual of omaha medigap comparison shows a clear gap in extra benefits. United American offers a straightforward Medigap policy without bundled discount programs. Their value proposition centers on competitive issue-age rates, strong claims processing, and a household discount of approximately 7%.

Mutual of Omaha includes several discount programs automatically with every Medigap policy. The EyeMed Vision Care plan offers 20–40% off eyewear and discounted eye exams at over 90,000 providers. The Amplifon hearing program provides 35–70% off hearing aids with a 60-day risk-free trial. Their Mutually Well fitness program costs $29.99 per month and covers access to more than 10,000 gyms nationwide.

Typically, beneficiaries who value vision and hearing discounts lean toward Mutual of Omaha. Those who prioritize lower long-term premiums through issue-age rating lean toward United American. Neither company offers SilverSneakers, telehealth add-ons, or OTC allowances — those benefits are more common with Medicare Advantage plans. Retirees should also review their homeowners coverage alongside Medicare choices, so consider visiting compare home insurance rates at Home Insure Guide for side-by-side quotes.

Financial Strength and Stability

Financial strength matters because you may hold a Medigap policy for decades. Both companies in the united american vs mutual of omaha medigap comparison earn an A+ (Superior) rating from AM Best. This is the second-highest possible grade. It indicates excellent ability to meet ongoing policyholder obligations. According to data from cms.gov, financial stability is a key factor when choosing a long-term insurance carrier.

United American is backed by Globe Life Inc., a publicly traded company on the NYSE. Globe Life has deep reserves and a long track record in supplemental insurance. United American’s NAIC complaint ratio sits well below 0.50, meaning it receives far fewer complaints than expected for its market share. This is one of the lowest ratios in the Medigap industry.

Mutual of Omaha is a Fortune 500 company with over $55 billion in total enterprise assets. As a mutual company, it is owned by its policyholders rather than Wall Street shareholders. Their NAIC complaint ratio of approximately 0.61 is also below the national median of 1.00. In most cases, both carriers demonstrate strong financial health. However, United American edges ahead slightly on complaint ratio, while Mutual of Omaha leads in total asset size and revenue. The united american vs mutual of omaha medigap stability question is essentially a tie at the top.

Which Medicare Carrier Should You Choose?

Choose United American if:

• You want issue-age pricing that avoids automatic age-based rate increases every year
• You plan to keep your Medigap policy for 15 or more years and want predictable long-term costs
• You prefer working with a local independent agent and value personalized service
• You do not need bundled vision, hearing, or gym discount programs

Choose Mutual of Omaha if:

• You want a lower starting premium at age 65 and are comfortable with attained-age increases
• You value automatic vision, hearing, and fitness discount programs included at no extra cost
• You want the option to enroll online without needing a local agent
• You want access to High-Deductible Plan G for the lowest possible monthly premium

The united american vs mutual of omaha medigap decision ultimately depends on your planning horizon. If you are enrolling at 65 and expect to hold your policy long-term, United American’s issue-age pricing typically delivers better value over time. If you want more enrollment flexibility, extra discount programs, and a lower entry price, Mutual of Omaha is the stronger pick. Both carriers are financially rock-solid and offer the most popular Medigap plan letters.

For most beneficiaries enrolling during their Medigap Open Enrollment Period, either carrier is a safe choice. However, the united american vs mutual of omaha medigap comparison favors United American for long-term savings and Mutual of Omaha for upfront affordability and extras. Compare quotes from both before making your final decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is United American or Mutual of Omaha cheaper for Medigap Plan G?

It depends on your age and location. Typically, United American may cost more initially because of issue-age pricing. However, over time, United American often becomes cheaper because rates do not increase based on your age each year. Mutual of Omaha starts lower but uses attained-age rating that rises annually.

Does United American or Mutual of Omaha offer Medicare Advantage plans?

Neither company offers Medicare Advantage plans. Both focus exclusively on Medigap supplement policies. In most cases, beneficiaries who want Medicare Advantage will need to look at carriers like UnitedHealthcare, Humana, or Aetna instead.

Which company has better extra benefits in the united american vs mutual of omaha medigap comparison?

Mutual of Omaha offers more bundled extras. For example, their policies include automatic EyeMed vision discounts, Amplifon hearing aid savings, and the Mutually Well gym program. United American does not bundle these types of discount programs with its Medigap plans.

Can I switch from United American to Mutual of Omaha or vice versa?

Yes, you can switch Medigap carriers at any time. However, outside of your initial Medigap Open Enrollment Period, you may need to pass medical underwriting. In most cases, switching is easiest during guaranteed issue situations or in states that offer annual Medigap open enrollment windows.

Are united american vs mutual of omaha medigap plans available in all 50 states?

Nearly. Mutual of Omaha sells Medigap in 49 states plus Washington, D.C. Massachusetts is the only state excluded. United American is available in approximately 47 to 49 states. Availability for both may vary based on specific plan letters and state regulations.

Compare More Medicare Insurance Companies

Looking for more Medicare carrier reviews, plan comparisons, and enrollment guides? Browse our complete library of Medicare resources.

Official Sources & Resources

For verified information on Medicare plans, ratings, and enrollment:

• Medicare.gov (Official): medicare.gov
• CMS.gov (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid): cms.gov
• AM Best (Financial Strength Ratings): ambest.com
• NAIC (Complaint Ratios): naic.org
• State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP): shiphelp.org
• Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF): kff.org

Content last reviewed April 2026. If you notice any outdated information, please contact us.

Related Guides

• Browse All Medicare Guides
• More Company Reviews
• Plan Comparisons
• Complete Medigap Plans Guide
• Medicare Advantage vs Medigap
• Understanding Medicare Costs